| about this site | who we are | site map | reading tips | teaching tips | student tips | build vocab |
| teaching vocab | hot links | visit Thai school | Bangkok Post | student weekly | home

This column is for self
study or classroom use and gives guided help with reading the wide variety of writing styles and topics that appear as feature articles in the Bangkok Post. The lessons include background information, skill
building practice and vocabulary explanations.
June 5, 2007
 

Animation and social criticism

INTRODUCTION
How can you discuss a sensitive topic without drawing too much criticism? Well, there are probably several different ways to accomplish this, but one might be to turn to animations. Social criticism has lately found many outlets in cartoons and comic books, and not the least in animated pictures.

Somehow the stands that animated characters make are, in the eyes of authorities, less serious than the stands that live actors make. This is true for literature as well. A long novel will definitely draw much more criticism than a comic book illustrating the same kind of thoughts and ideas.

The animated film Persepolis, which has been picked into the top section of Cannes, isn't, however, really judgmental. The director/writer, describing the political climate in Iran during the 1970s and 1980s through the eyes of a young girl, seem to have a different kind of agenda.

Her goal isn't really political, but humanistic. The director, Iranian-French Marjane Satrapi, states that "if Western audiences end up considering Iranians as human beings just like the rest of us ... then I'd feel like I've done something". If an animated film can accomplish this, maybe the genre should be taken a little bit more seriously. What do you think?

accomplish
to succeed in doing something good

rigid
not able to change or be changed easily

stands
opinions, especially ones which are made public

judgmental
quick to criticize people

agenda
a list of aims or possible future achievements

humanistic
relating to people, and the importance of always putting people and their needs in the center

genre
a particular style or type of literature, film, art or music that you can recognize because of its special features.



OUR STORY FROM THE BANGKOK POST

Stubborn spirit

New animated film finds bitter humor in Iran's Islamic Revolution

Mixing textbook exposition with pungent satire and childlike humor, "Persepolis" attempts to tell a national history through a family history.

The streets of Teheran in 1978 heaved with mobs of protestors at the peak of the Islamic Revolution that overthrew the Western-backed Shah regime. But as is the case with many historic revolutions, this one replaced what seemed bad with something worse. It sounds like a joke that's probably funny to everyone except Iranians.

Yet some dare to see the bitter humor in it. The social upheaval of Iran in the 1970s and '80s is seen through the eyes of a precocious girl in Persepolis, a black-and-white animated film that earned its place in the coveted Competition program of this year's Festival de Cannes. Adapted from a graphic novel by Iranian-French Marjane Satrapi, this autobiographical movie, directed by the author herself along with Vincent Paronnaud, will surely court sour gripes from the Iranian government, though Persepolis, despite its political nature, will hardly contribute any fresh dimension to the ongoing tension between the Ahmadinejad administration and the White House.

"Persepolis" has aroused much curiosity since it was picked into the top section of Cannes, which is dominated by revered auteurs this year. This 2D cartoon, drawn by a French animation studio that chose to use a simple, sometimes whimsical drawing to narrate serious, at times disturbing stories, may not be a strong contender to win the Palme d'Or, but the film will surely receive much publicity due to its nature and origin.

''When the Persepolis graphic novels were first published [in France, in 2000], they had an immediate success and I got several offers to adapt them - I even got offered one to make a Beverly Hills 90210-style TV show and a movie starring Jennifer Lopez!'', said Satrapi. ''To be honest, I thought my work was finished when I completed the graphic novels, but when I started talking with my co-director Vincent about the film project I realized I not only had the opportunity to work with him, but also to experience something completely new.''

The movie begins with Satrapi as a child during the 1978 revolution, and follows her for 16 years as she grows up witnessing her relatives jailed and killed on charges of being Communists. Forced to cover herself, the young Satrapi reacts by embracing rock music and imported pop-culture, dodging the bearded Thought Police who roam Teheran's alleys catching unveiled women. She is later sent to study in Vienna, where she begins her uneasy assimilation into the Western mindset, before returning to Iran and later leaving for Paris.

Mixing textbook exposition with pungent satire and childlike humor, Persepolis attempts to tell a national history through a family history. It gives us a casual sketch of a place where the people negotiate their way through the cracks in the system to sustain their need for happiness and freedom. The elastic black-and-white drawings render a stylized realism that accentuates the grotesque figures of the oppressors as well as the stubborn spirit of Satrapi and her parents. It's rather clear, however, that although Satrapi resents the unfairness and rigid control of Iran, she's torn between the longing for her homeland and the more practical choice of remaining in the West.

''The film is not judgmental'', said the director. ''It doesn't say this is right and this is wrong. It just shows that the situation has many layers. This isn't a politically oriented film with a message to sell. It is first and foremost a film about my love for my family.''

''But if Western audiences end up considering Iranians as human beings just like the rest of us, and not just as abstract notions like Islamic fundamentalists or part of the Axis of Evil, then I'd feel like I've done something.''

It's unlikely that "Persepolis" will get a release in Thailand. The best chance is that one of the many film festivals in Bangkok will be interested in screening it.

heaved
filled with; had a lot of

mobs
large groups of people that are often violent or not organized

dare
to be brave enough to do something that might be dangerous

bitter humor
a kind of humor that relies on experiences that caused deep pain or anger

upheaval
a very big change that causes difficulty or confusion

precocious
children who have the confidence or skill of an adult

coveted
wanted something very much, especially something that someone else has

adapted
changed a book or play so that it could be made into a film or television program

autobiographical
a book written by someone about their own life

court
court controversy/danger/disaster, etc., to behave in a way that risks bad results

sour gripes
angry feelings

aroused
made someone have a particular feeling or reaction

revered
respected and admired someone very much

auteurs
filmmakers whose individual style and complete control over all elements of production give a film its personal and unique stamp

whimsical
unusual in a way that is slightly funny

narrate
to tell the story in a book, film, play, etc.

disturbing
unpleasant in a way that makes people feel anxious or upset

contender
someone who competes with other people to try to win something

witnessing
seeing something happen, especially an accident or crime

embracing
accepting new ideas, beliefs, methods, etc., in an enthusiastic way

dodging
moving quickly to avoid someone or something

roam
to move around a place without any purpose

unveiled
removed the thin piece of material that covers a woman's face

mindset
a person's way of thinking and their opinions

assimilation
to take in, fit into, or become similar to something new

exposition
the way something is presented

pungent
describes a very strong smell or taste, sometimes one that is unpleasantly strong

satire
a way of criticizing people or ideas in a humorous way, or a piece of writing or play which uses this style

negotiate
to manage to travel along a difficult route

sustain
to keep alive

elastic (drawings)
drawings that are stretched out and a little bit out of the ordinary

render
to cause something or someone to be in a particular state or condition

accentuates
emphasizes something so that people notice it

grotesque
strange and unpleasant, especially in a ridiculous or slightly frightening way

stubborn
determined not to change your ideas, plans, etc., although other people want you to

resents
feels angry and upset about a situation or about something that someone has done

abstract
relating to ideas and not real things


Read our other instant lesson here.

Return to our home page.

| ? The Post Publishing Public Co., Ltd.
All rights reserved 2007
|
Last modified: June 5, 2007